James Turk BlogJames Turk BlogJames Turk BlogJames Turk Blog
  • Blog
  • About
    • About FGMR
    • James Turk
    • GoldMoney
  • Books
    • Money and Liberty
    • The Money Bubble
    • The Collapse of the Dollar
Next Previous

From Brexit to Texit; Secessionist Sensationalism

James Turk 27 June, 2016

Immediately following the referendum held in the United Kingdom, deciding its position in the EU, social media was resonating with similar secessionist enthusiasm from across the Atlantic. The Texas secede movement, with proponents like President of the Texas Nationalist Movement Danieal Miller took advantage of the post EU referendum hype, by popularizing the ‘Texit’ hashtag.

While the sentiment may be similar in some sense, the scenarios may have some stark distinctions. As the Texas Tribune suggests:

It is also important to note that the European Union is a loose association of compound states with pre-existing protocols for a nation to exit. In contrast, the U.S. Constitution contains procedures for admitting new states into the nation, but none for a state to leave

In making sense of the situation, let us first analyze what the claims are.

To Leave, Or Not to Leave 

The main sentiment promoted by the secessionist campaign is the issue of cultural integrity, and historic claim to independence. The essence of their argument is that they have a unique cultural identity, characterized by their own values which need to be upheld, independent of interference from national legislature.

In the words of Daniel Miller during an interview with the Guardian:

 We come from a heritage of people that carved an empire out of a wilderness. The fact of the matter is that Texas has always been rough. When people first moved to Texas and settled here, you were independent or you died

They also seem to tacitly support the notion that the ‘central bureaucracy’ of the United States is ineffective in the equitable use of tax dollars, and that ceding to such a bureaucracy is against their best interests – both politically and economically. However, certain undeniable pragmatic complications exist with the entire idea of seceding. Legality is one of them, and is covered in a section below. The other facts include Texas’ dependence on Federal support for a vast spectrum of public goods and services. These range from; healthcare, to education to federal courthouses, prisons and national parks.

Additionally, secession would also place the burden of national security and defense on the shoulders of the newly formed nation, without access to the resources of the Union. A 2009 poll held by the media company Rasmussen Reports, showed that less than 20% of Texans themselves were open to the idea of seceding. While there is room for speculation about how this may have changed over the years, and if at all it would have, it becomes quite unnecessary given the legal impediment to actual secession, as discussed below.

Political Movement

In addition to the recent sensationalism riding the wave of publicity in the aftermath of the Brexit referendum, the Texit movement has had quite a few prominent moments in its history. In 2012, a petition for secession was brought to the White House, signed by 125,000 individuals. The petition met with the expected negative response, citing the absence of legal grounds for breaking away from the Union.

Legality

The fundamental impediment to secession is the US constitutional principle of the Perpetual Union, which disallows states to overthrow the US constitution or withdraw from the Union.

The Texas Tribune puts the matter to rest thus:

Simply put, the answer is no. Historical and legal precedents make it clear that Texas could not pull off a Texit — at least not legally.

It then goes on to clarify:

Many historians believe that when the Confederacy surrendered at Appomattox in 1865, the idea of secession was also defeated, according to McDaniel. The Union’s victory set a precedent that states could not legally secede.

 

 

James Turk

More posts by James Turk

JAMES TURK

james_turk_blog

GOLDMONEY

GoldMoney_Inc

MONEY AND LIBERTY

collapse_of_the_dollar_james_turk

MONEY BUBBLE

the_money_bubble_james_turk

COLLAPSE OF THE DOLLAR

collapse_of_the_dollar_james_turk

COMING COLLAPSE OF THE DOLLAR

collapse_of_the_dollar_james_turk

GET GOLDMONEY INSIGHTS

GOLD & SILVER LIVE PRICES

@FGMR RECENT TWEETS

  • Value of #currency depends on supply/demand. #USD supply is #M2, which #Fed is causing to fall. But the #dollar is… https://t.co/mf1LJ1xZJv

    2 days ago
  • Debate about failing #banks needs a realistic look at the cause of failures. There's more to it than just bad judge… https://t.co/u6TZPxNCK0

    7 days ago

FEATURED VIDEO – July 8, 2022

FEATURED VIDEO – January 10, 2022

Categories

  • Articles
  • Books
  • Briefcase
  • Gold
  • Gold News
  • Market Commentaries
  • Silver
  • Trading
  • Uncategorized

TOPICS

bitcoin bonds central banks currencies debt dollar doug casey ecb economy euro fed gold greece hyperinflation inflation markets mining stocks MMGA money oil Politics QE recommended silver stock market trading Trump usd us dollar Washington

ARCHIVES

  • You may also like

    The Forgotten Fourth Function of Money & G-SIBs

    Read now
  • You may also like

    A Century of Fascism

    Read now
  • You may also like

    House Price Fallacies

    Read now
  • You may also like

    Natural Money

    Read now
  • You may also like

    James Turk Interviewed By The Epoch Times

    Read now
  • You may also like

    Looking At the Value of Silver

    Read now
  • You may also like

    The Origin of Bitcoin

    Read now
  • You may also like

    My Perspective on Money and Liberty

    Read now

ABOUT

FGMR My objective is to share with you my views on gold, which in recent decades has become one of the world’s most misunderstood asset classes. This low level of knowledge about gold creates a wonderful opportunity and competitive edge to everyone who truly understands gold and money.

RECENT POSTS

  • The Forgotten Fourth Function of Money & G-SIBs

    Money is routinely defined by what it does, rather than what it

    13 December, 2022
  • A Century of Fascism

    In 1922 Benito Mussolini became prime minister of Italy, putting that country

    31 August, 2022

TAGS

bitcoin bonds central banks currencies debt dollar doug casey ecb economy euro fed gold greece hyperinflation inflation markets mining stocks MMGA money oil Politics QE recommended silver stock market trading Trump usd us dollar Washington
Copyright © 2001-2022 Free Gold Money Report | All Rights Reserved
  • FGMR
  • GoldMoney
  • James Turk
  • Money and Liberty
  • The Collapse of the Dollar
James Turk Blog