James Turk BlogJames Turk BlogJames Turk BlogJames Turk Blog
  • Blog
  • Videos
  • About
    • About FGMR
    • James Turk
    • Goldmoney
  • Books
    • Money and Liberty
    • The Money Bubble
    • The Collapse of the Dollar
Next Previous

Is Gold a Commodity?

James Turk 26 May, 2016

Here’s a question that might have you pondering: Is gold a commodity?

More importantly, are we doing a disservice to the gold industry by calling gold a commodity? These may sound like silly questions, but hear me out.

Last month I participated as a keynote speaker at the Asia Mining Conference in Singapore. There were a number of presentations in which gold was mentioned along with lead, zinc, copper and many other commodities, including soybeans and other agricultural products. These presentations then looked at annual supply and demand data in order to analyse their price.

The interaction of supply and demand obviously determines an item’s price. While annual supply is a big factor in the price of commodities, the annual supply of newly mined gold does not have much of an impact on the gold price. The real supply of gold is its aboveground stock, nearly all of which can be sold at a moment’s notice. This aboveground stock is all the gold mined throughout history, and with new mine production it grows consistently around 1.75% per annum.

The aboveground gold stock and its relatively small, consistent annual growth are among the distinguishing features that set gold apart from commodities because they are consumed and disappear. Gold does not get consumed, nor does it disappear. It gets accumulated.

All the gold mined throughout history still exists. It forms an aboveground stock weighing about 170,000 tonnes, which if fabricated into one large cube could slide under the arches of the Eiffel Tower.

There are other distinguishing features that set gold apart from commodities. For example, gold doesn’t have different grades. Not only does gold mined 2000 years ago by the Romans still exist in the aboveground stock, it is exactly the same as gold being mined throughout the world today.

Nor does gold deteriorate over time. It does not corrode, rust or spoil.

Clearly, gold is very different from commodities because none can match gold’s attributes, so gold is therefore something special. But gold has one other feature that unquestionably sets it apart from commodities. Gold has an interest rate.

Gold for delivery in the future has a higher price than gold due for delivery today. This structure is called contango, and the difference in price is gold’s interest rate. No commodity – or indeed, no other tangible asset – has an interest rate.

While sometimes commodities trade in contango, they also trade in backwardation and have significant storage costs. In comparison, the cost of storing gold is inconsequential relative to the value being stored.

For example, the London Metal Exchange charges about 4% per annum to store copper. Gold storage in GoldMoney can be as low as 0.0012% per annum, which is less than some banks charge for checking account fees. So again, gold is different.

Here’s my point. Like commodities, gold is a tangible asset, but it is a unique tangible asset. Gold has attributes that set it apart from commodities, and therefore cannot be considered as a commodity. Nor should gold even be called a commodity as that belittles gold’s special status by overlooking those unique features that make gold different from commodities.

The only feature gold and commodities share is their tangibility, which is the essential nature of all things that are real. Gold is a unique tangible asset with exceptional qualities.

So if gold is not a commodity, what is it? Gold is money.

James Turk

More posts by James Turk

  • You may also like

    Whether Inflation or Deflation, Gold Wins

    Read now
  • You may also like

    How To Make America Great Again

    Read now
  • You may also like

    Is Gold Overvalued?

    Read now
  • You may also like

    Rising Fear Always Sends Gold Soaring

    Read now
  • You may also like

    Heading Toward Another U.S. Government Default

    Read now
  • You may also like

    The Forgotten Fourth Function of Money & G-SIBs

    Read now
  • You may also like

    A Century of Fascism

    Read now
  • You may also like

    House Price Fallacies

    Read now

ABOUT

FGMR My objective is to share with you my views on gold, which in recent decades has become one of the world’s most misunderstood asset classes. This low level of knowledge about gold creates a wonderful opportunity and competitive edge to everyone who truly understands gold and money.

RECENT POSTS

  • Whether Inflation or Deflation, Gold Wins

    In January 1934, the dollar was devalued against gold by 69% when

    24 January, 2025
  • How To Make America Great Again

    If I were advising President Trump, here are the recommendations – with

    14 November, 2024

TAGS

bitcoin bonds central banks constitution currencies debt dollar doug casey ecb economy euro fear index fed gold greece hyperinflation inflation maga markets mining stocks MMGA money oil Politics QE recommended silver stock market trading Trump usd us dollar Washington
Copyright © Free Gold Money Report | All Rights Reserved
  • FGMR
  • Goldmoney
  • James Turk
  • Money and Liberty
  • The Collapse of the Dollar
  • Videos
James Turk Blog